We have a lot of conversations about pizza around here. Is it worthy, is it too low brow, is it the ultimate barometer of a country's tomato quality?

We haven't quite landed on the above questions; the only thing we have decided is that if we are to write about pizza, it must truly be excellent.

Well, this place used to be called Best Pizza and Dive Bar. It seems there is placed called Best Pizza in Brooklyn so they may have needed to give up the front part of their name. And when we first heard of the place we worried they may not live up to their name.

However, we went to try it out, not because of the pizza, but because this stretch of Montauk Highway on Napeague where they first. opened up was a special spot that had the kind of casual laid-back apres-surf energy that we adore - they have since moved to an equally laid back location. With sometimes awesome bands and an always awesome jukebox.

And we love it. We love the bar, we love the back yard, we love the music, and actually, the pizza is the best pizza you can find in the Hamptons.

Try their signature Grandma's pizza, or the thin crust Margherita. We actually prefer the latter, but their Granda's will be one of the best Grandma's you'll ever have.

HOURS

Seasonal, Closed for Winter

Check for Hours

NEW ADDRESS

466 Westlake Drive

Montauk NY

CONTACT

https://divebarpizza.com

ph: 631 668 8378

LEAD-IN IMAGE

Dive Bar Pizza / Facebook