For us, there are two reasons to go to John’s Drive-In in Montauk.
The first is that the restaurant, which opened in 1967, evokes memories of the 1970s and 80s with a particular smell of fry grease and burgers that we haven’t sensed since driving to roadside stands with our grandparents decades ago.
The second is that John’s Drive-In is making some seriously good milkshakes with its homemade ice cream.
The frosty drinks are expensive ($9.90), cash only and small in size, but they are delicious and surprisingly filling.
The Oreo flavors – original, mint, fudge, banana, coffee and pumpkin – are the crowd favorites here.
If you like milkshakes and Oreo cookies – and have some pocket money to spare – make a stop here.
TIP: Sample before you order. We almost ordered a Banana Oreo shake, and while we liked the ice cream, we made a better decision by going with the original instead.
NOT TO BE CONFUSED with the equally awesome John’s Pancake House nearby. See that card below.
CONTACT
https://johnsdriveinmontauk.com
677 NY-27, Montauk, NY 11954, USA
IMAGES
Wonder Shuffle
The Joy of Finding Out.
Wonder Shuffle is a mobile-optimised site tailored to jet setters, culture lovers, luxury shoppers and voracious readers of news, information and magazines.
DJK Universal Holdings Limited
Latest News
Our Favorite Curated Shops
How to Stay Cozy in NYC and the Hamptons
Where to Visit in 2025
Our Story
About Us
Premium Accounts
Points & Loyalty
FAQs
The Wonder Shuffle Pledge
Useful Links
Privacy
Terms & Conditions
Site Map
Contact Us
Get the Newsletter